Liquidity Risk & Opportunity Cost
These concepts relate to the ability to access funds and the trade-offs inherent in every investment decision.
Liquidity Risk
Liquidity risk is the risk of not being able to sell an investment quickly at a fair price. It also includes the risk of having to sell at a significant discount due to market conditions.
Characteristics of Illiquid Investments
| Indicator | Description |
|---|---|
| Wide bid-ask spreads | Large gap between buy and sell prices |
| Low trading volume | Few buyers and sellers |
| Long settlement | Extended time to complete transactions |
| Price impact | Large orders move the price significantly |
| Lock-up periods | Cannot sell for specified time |
Liquidity Spectrum
| More Liquid | Characteristics | Less Liquid | Characteristics |
|---|---|---|---|
| Treasury bills | Active market, daily trading | Private equity | No public market |
| Large-cap stocks | High volume, tight spreads | Hedge funds | Lock-up periods |
| Major ETFs | Continuous trading | Real estate | Long sale process |
| Money market funds | Same-day redemption | Limited partnerships | Illiquid secondary market |
| Blue chips | Millions of shares traded | Penny stocks | Thin trading, wide spreads |
| Investment-grade bonds | Active secondary market | Collectibles | Find willing buyer |
Types of Liquidity Risk
1. Market Liquidity Risk
Risk that an asset cannot be sold quickly due to insufficient market activity.
Example: A small-cap stock with only 5,000 shares traded daily. An investor wanting to sell 50,000 shares would significantly impact the price.
2. Funding Liquidity Risk
Risk that an investor cannot meet short-term obligations due to inability to sell assets or obtain financing.
Example: An investor must sell illiquid holdings at a loss to meet a margin call during a market decline.
3. Asset-Liability Mismatch
Risk when short-term obligations exceed available liquid assets.
Example: A mutual fund with illiquid holdings facing heavy redemption requests.
Liquidity Premium
Investors demand higher returns for less liquid investments:
| Investment | Approximate Liquidity Premium |
|---|---|
| Treasury bills | None (benchmark) |
| Corporate bonds | 0.5-1.0% |
| Private equity | 3-5% |
| Real estate | 2-4% |
Why? Illiquid investments tie up capital, create uncertainty about exit prices, and may require forced sales at disadvantageous times.
Managing Liquidity Risk
| Strategy | Description |
|---|---|
| Match to time horizon | Illiquid investments only with long horizons |
| Emergency reserves | Keep 3-6 months expenses in liquid assets |
| Understand lock-ups | Know when funds can be accessed |
| Diversify liquidity | Mix liquid and illiquid holdings |
| Laddering | Stagger bond maturities for regular liquidity |
Opportunity Cost
Opportunity cost is the potential benefit lost by choosing one alternative over another. It represents the "cost" of the path not taken.
Opportunity Cost Formula
Opportunity Cost = Return on Best Alternative − Return on Chosen Investment
Investment Examples
| Scenario | Opportunity Cost |
|---|---|
| Hold cash (2%) when stocks return 15% | 13% opportunity cost |
| Buy bonds (5%) when stocks return 12% | 7% opportunity cost |
| Buy stocks (10%) when bonds return 3% | -7% (you benefited) |
| Hold CD (3%) when money market pays 4% | 1% opportunity cost |
Detailed Example
An investor holds $100,000 in a money market fund earning 2%:
- Money market return: $100,000 × 2% = $2,000
- Stock market returned 12%: Would have earned $12,000
- Opportunity cost: $12,000 − $2,000 = $10,000
The "safe" choice cost $10,000 in potential returns.
Time Value Component
Opportunity cost includes the time value of money:
When money is tied up in an illiquid or low-return investment:
- It cannot compound elsewhere
- Lost returns compound over time
- Early opportunity costs have the largest long-term impact
Example: A 25-year-old keeps $10,000 in a savings account (1%) instead of investing in stocks (hypothetical 8%):
- After 40 years in savings: ~$14,900
- After 40 years in stocks: ~$217,200
- Lifetime opportunity cost: >$200,000
Opportunity Cost Considerations
| Factor | Consideration |
|---|---|
| Risk tolerance | Lower-return investments may be appropriate for risk-averse investors |
| Liquidity needs | Cash has value beyond its return (flexibility) |
| Transaction costs | Switching investments has costs |
| Taxes | Realizing gains triggers taxes |
| Peace of mind | Sometimes the opportunity cost of worry exceeds return differences |
Important: Opportunity cost is not always just about returns. Safety, liquidity, and peace of mind have real value that may justify lower returns.
Opportunity Cost vs. Sunk Cost
| Concept | Definition | Relevant to Decisions? |
|---|---|---|
| Opportunity cost | What you give up by making a choice | YES—should influence decisions |
| Sunk cost | What you already spent/lost | NO—should NOT influence future decisions |
Sunk Cost Fallacy: Continuing a poor investment because "I've already invested so much." Past losses are irrelevant to future decisions.
In Practice: How Investment Advisers Apply This
Liquidity assessment:
- Evaluate client liquidity needs before recommending illiquid investments
- Ensure emergency reserves are in place
- Match investment horizon to liquidity characteristics
- Explain lock-up periods and redemption restrictions
Opportunity cost communication:
- Help clients understand trade-offs between safety and growth
- Discuss real costs of holding excess cash
- Consider opportunity cost in asset allocation decisions
- But also recognize that peace of mind has value
On the Exam
The Series 65 exam tests your understanding of:
- Liquidity risk definition and characteristics
- Which investments are more vs. less liquid
- Liquidity premium concept
- Opportunity cost definition and calculation
- Trade-offs between liquidity, safety, and returns
Expect 1-2 questions on these concepts. Common formats include identifying which investment has highest liquidity risk and understanding opportunity cost scenarios.
Key Takeaways
- Liquidity risk is the risk of not being able to sell quickly at fair price
- Illiquid investments include private equity, real estate, hedge funds, limited partnerships
- Investors demand a liquidity premium (higher returns) for illiquid investments
- Opportunity cost is the return given up by choosing one investment over another
- Match investment liquidity to time horizon
- Maintain emergency reserves in liquid assets
- Opportunity cost applies to time (not just money)
- Sunk costs should NOT influence future investment decisions
Which investment would typically have the HIGHEST liquidity risk?
Opportunity cost in investing refers to:
An investor demands higher expected returns from illiquid investments. This additional return is called:
3.6 Risk Measurement & Portfolio Theory
Continue learning