Key Takeaways
- General liability insurance covers bodily injury and property damage to third parties
- Commercial General Liability (CGL) policies are essential for Hawaii businesses
- Hawaii's tourism economy creates significant liability exposures for hotels, activities, and restaurants
- Liquor liability is important for bars and restaurants serving alcohol in tourist areas
- Professional liability insurance protects service providers from errors and omissions claims
General Liability Insurance in Hawaii
General liability insurance protects businesses and individuals from claims of bodily injury, property damage, and personal injury to third parties. Hawaii's tourism economy creates unique liability exposures.
Commercial General Liability (CGL) Insurance
What CGL Covers
Coverage A: Bodily Injury and Property Damage Liability
Covers claims for:
- Bodily injury to customers, visitors, or the public
- Property damage caused by business operations
- Medical expenses for injured parties
- Legal defense costs and settlements
- Judgments and court costs
Common CGL Claims in Hawaii:
- Slip and fall accidents in hotels or restaurants
- Tourist injuries during activities (snorkeling, hiking, zip-lining)
- Property damage from business operations
- Product liability for sold or manufactured goods
- Injury to visitors on business premises
Coverage B: Personal and Advertising Injury
Covers claims for:
- Libel, slander, defamation
- False advertising or misrepresentation
- Copyright or trademark infringement
- Invasion of privacy
- Wrongful eviction
Coverage C: Medical Payments
- Pays medical expenses regardless of fault
- No-fault coverage (up to policy limit, typically $5,000-10,000)
- Covers injuries on premises or from operations
- Goodwill coverage to prevent lawsuits
CGL Policy Limits
Occurrence Limits:
- Per Occurrence Limit: Maximum per single incident
- Aggregate Limit: Maximum per policy period (annual)
Typical Limits:
- $1,000,000 per occurrence
- $2,000,000 general aggregate
- $2,000,000 products/completed operations aggregate
- $1,000,000 personal & advertising injury
- $5,000 medical payments (per person)
Higher Limits for Hawaii Businesses:
- Tourism businesses often carry $2M-5M occurrence limits
- Hotels and resorts may carry $5M-10M+ limits
- Umbrella/excess liability policies for higher limits
Hawaii-Specific Liability Exposures
Tourism and Hospitality Liability
Hawaii's economy relies heavily on tourism, creating significant liability exposures:
Hotels and Resorts:
- Guest injuries (slip and fall, pool accidents)
- Property damage to guest belongings
- Beach and pool drownings or near-drownings
- Injuries from recreational activities (surfing, snorkeling, water sports)
- Food poisoning or foodborne illness
- Premises liability for grounds and facilities
Tour Operators and Activity Providers:
- Injuries during activities (helicopter tours, diving, zip-lining, hiking)
- Equipment failures causing injury
- Inadequate instruction or supervision
- Transportation accidents
- Ocean activities (drowning, shark encounters, jellyfish stings)
Restaurants and Bars:
- Slip and fall on wet floors or uneven surfaces
- Food poisoning or allergic reactions
- Burns from hot food or equipment
- Liquor liability (overserving patrons)
- Premises liability for parking areas and walkways
Outdoor Activity Liability
Hawaii's natural environment creates unique exposures:
Ocean-Related Activities:
- Snorkeling, diving, surfing, paddleboarding injuries
- Drownings and near-drownings
- Marine life encounters (sharks, jellyfish, sea urchins)
- Coral cuts and infections
- Strong currents and riptides
Land-Based Activities:
- Hiking trail injuries (falls, heat exhaustion)
- Volcano viewing hazards
- ATV and off-road vehicle accidents
- Zip-lining and aerial adventure parks
- Rock climbing and rappelling
Waivers and Liability:
- Waivers may limit but not eliminate liability
- Gross negligence cannot be waived
- Minors' waivers unenforceable in Hawaii
- Proper waivers still recommended but not complete protection
Exam Tip: Hawaii law prohibits waiving liability for gross negligence. Activity providers cannot completely eliminate liability through waivers, especially for injuries caused by reckless or intentional conduct.
Premises Liability
Business Owners' Duties:
- Maintain safe premises for invitees and customers
- Warn of known hazards
- Inspect for dangerous conditions
- Repair hazards promptly
- Adequate lighting and security
Common Premises Claims:
- Slip and fall on wet surfaces (common in rainy Hawaii climate)
- Uneven walkways or stairs
- Inadequate lighting in parking areas
- Swimming pool accidents
- Elevator and escalator injuries
- Falling objects (coconuts, tree branches)
Product Liability
Manufacturers and Sellers:
- Defective product injuries
- Failure to warn of dangers
- Manufacturing defects
- Design defects
- Breach of warranty
Hawaii Considerations:
- Imported goods (significant port activity)
- Tourist souvenirs and gifts
- Food and beverage products
- Beach and water equipment
Liquor Liability Insurance
Liquor liability (dram shop) insurance is critical for businesses serving alcohol in Hawaii.
Hawaii Liquor Liability Law
Dram Shop Liability:
- Bars, restaurants, and servers can be held liable for overserving patrons
- Liability for injuries caused by intoxicated patrons to third parties
- Liability for serving minors or obviously intoxicated persons
When Liability Attaches:
- Overserving: Continuing to serve obviously intoxicated person
- Serving Minors: Serving alcohol to persons under 21
- Proximate Cause: Intoxication proximately caused injury to third party
Not Covered by CGL:
- Liquor liability typically excluded from standard CGL policies
- Separate liquor liability policy or endorsement required
- Essential for bars, nightclubs, restaurants with alcohol service
Liquor Liability Coverage
What It Covers:
- Bodily injury caused by intoxicated patron
- Property damage caused by intoxicated patron
- Legal defense costs
- Settlements and judgments
Typical Limits:
- $1,000,000 per occurrence
- $2,000,000 aggregate
- Often matches CGL limits
Hawaii Tourism Impact:
- Waikiki bars and nightclubs face high exposure
- Tourist unfamiliarity with alcohol tolerance
- Vacation "party" mentality increases risk
- Higher limits recommended for tourist-area establishments
Professional Liability Insurance
Professional liability (Errors & Omissions) insurance protects service providers from negligence claims.
Who Needs Professional Liability
Covered Professions:
- Insurance agents and brokers (E&O insurance)
- Real estate agents and brokers
- Attorneys (malpractice insurance)
- Accountants and CPAs
- Financial advisors and planners
- Architects and engineers
- Medical professionals (malpractice)
- Technology and IT consultants
Hawaii Insurance Producer E&O
Coverage for Insurance Producers:
- Errors in coverage recommendations
- Failure to obtain requested coverage
- Failure to explain policy exclusions
- Missing policy renewals
- Misrepresentation of coverage
Common E&O Claims:
- Lava zone property insurance failures
- Hurricane coverage gaps not explained
- Flood insurance not recommended (then flood occurs)
- Condo association coverage inadequacies
- Failure to increase limits when values rise
Recommended E&O Limits for Hawaii Producers:
- Minimum: $1,000,000 per claim / $1,000,000 aggregate
- Preferred: $2,000,000 per claim / $2,000,000 aggregate
- High-volume agencies: $5,000,000+ limits
E&O Premiums:
- Based on annual commissions/premium volume
- Claims history significantly impacts premium
- Deductibles: $2,500-25,000 typical
Medical Malpractice in Hawaii
High-Risk Environment:
- Hawaii has shortage of medical specialists
- High costs lead to large malpractice awards
- Tourist medical emergencies common
- Difficult to attract doctors due to costs
Malpractice Limits:
- Physicians typically carry $1M-3M per occurrence limits
- Hospitals carry $5M-20M+ limits
- Specialists (surgeons) may carry higher limits
Umbrella and Excess Liability
Umbrella policies provide additional liability coverage above underlying policies.
How Umbrella Coverage Works
Coverage:
- Provides additional limits above CGL, auto, employers' liability
- Typically $1M-10M+ limits
- Broader coverage than underlying policies (may cover some excluded perils)
- Must maintain required underlying limits
Example:
- CGL policy: $1M per occurrence limit
- Umbrella policy: $5M additional
- Large claim: $3.5M judgment
- CGL pays: $1M
- Umbrella pays: $2.5M
- Total coverage: $3.5M (claim fully paid)
Underlying Policy Requirements:
- Must maintain minimum underlying limits (e.g., $1M CGL, $1M auto)
- Umbrella won't respond if underlying limits insufficient
- Annual verification of underlying coverage required
Who Needs Umbrella Coverage
Recommended for:
- High net worth individuals (protect assets)
- Business owners with significant exposures
- Hotels, resorts, and tourism businesses
- Activity providers with high injury risk
- Any business facing catastrophic loss potential
Benefits:
- Affordable additional coverage ($150-500 per $1M typical)
- Protects personal and business assets
- Peace of mind for catastrophic claims
Workers' Compensation in Hawaii
Workers' compensation insurance is mandatory for Hawaii employers.
Who Must Carry Workers' Comp
Mandatory for:
- All employers with one or more employees
- Full-time, part-time, and temporary employees
- Family members employed in business (with exceptions)
- Corporate officers (can opt out in some cases)
Coverage:
- Medical expenses for work-related injuries
- Lost wages (2/3 of average weekly wage)
- Temporary total disability
- Permanent partial disability
- Permanent total disability
- Death benefits to dependents
Hawaii Workers' Comp Specifics
No-Fault System:
- Employees receive benefits regardless of fault
- Employer immune from tort lawsuits (exclusive remedy)
- Exceptions: Intentional injuries, intoxication, willful misconduct
Benefits:
- Medical: All reasonable and necessary treatment
- Temporary Total Disability: 2/3 of wages (subject to max)
- Permanent Disability: Based on impairment rating
- Vocational Rehabilitation: Job retraining if cannot return to work
Premiums:
- Based on payroll and risk classification
- Experience modification factor (claims history)
- Tourism/hospitality often higher rates (injury risk)
Penalties for No Workers' Comp
Criminal Penalties:
- Misdemeanor: Fine up to $10,000, imprisonment up to 1 year
- Each day without coverage is separate violation
Civil Penalties:
- Stop work order (business shut down until coverage obtained)
- Back premiums owed
- Personal liability for employee injuries
- Fines and assessments
Can Hawaii businesses completely eliminate liability through waivers signed by customers?
Is liquor liability covered under a standard Commercial General Liability (CGL) policy?
How many employees must a Hawaii business have before workers' compensation insurance becomes mandatory?